When Napoleon first encountered a Camembert cheese, legend has it, he was so delighted he kissed the waitress who plonked it in entrance of him. Setting apart the inappropriateness of this gesture, the French emperor clearly acknowledged a winner.
Produced in France’s northwestern area of Normandy in numerous kinds since not less than the 18th century, the cheese – creamy, pungent and gooey – is now considered France’s favourite.
Which is why latest headlines about Camembert’s imminent loss of life on account of a fungal disaster have induced panic amongst followers of this historic fromage. Scientists, it appears, have warned that issues with French cheese’s industrial manufacturing could have long-term penalties for its future.
Alarm was raised in January when a latest examine by scientists at Paris-Saclay College recognized that the primary fungus utilized in creating Camembert and different cheeses was more and more briefly provide because of the industrial manufacturing strategies used to maintain up with demand.
And whereas that may spell hassle for quite a lot of dairy choices, some have taken this to imply that poor Camembert – which is handily bought in its personal picket field – is headed for the grave.
“Blue cheeses could also be beneath risk, however the state of affairs is far worse for Camembert, which is already on the verge of extinction,” the French Nationwide Middle for Scientific Analysis (CNRS) mentioned in its report in regards to the findings. Elsewhere, one other headline warned of a looming “cheese disaster,” including, “say a prayer for Camembert!”
The cheese stakes couldn’t be larger. Alongside the Louvre, high fashion and the Eiffel Tower, Camembert is a nationwide treasure beloved the world over – as existential to the French as existentialism.
“What’s the everyday picture of France? A bottle of pink wine, a baguette and a Camembert,” says Anne-Marie Cantin, a veteran cheesemonger and president choose of the 2023 French nationwide Camembert competitors. “It’s our nationwide cheese.”
Previous mould
On the coronary heart of the issue is Penicillium camemberti, a fungus utilized in cheesemaking that offers Camembert its white rind and helps develop each the cheese’s wealthy buttery umami taste and its palpable aroma of unwashed socks.
P. camemberti is, say the Paris-Saclay scientists, experiencing issues reproducing, largely because of the pressures of business manufacturing. Not a lot efficiency nervousness per se, however the consequence of an asexual fungal cultivation course of that, on account of an excessive lack of genetic range, is working on empty.
Camembert, and comparable cheeses like Brie, had been as soon as aged in caves or hâloirs (drying rooms), the place naturally occurring mould spores gave them blue or generally yellow-brown rinds. On the flip of the final century, Penicillium camemberti was launched, changing the indigenous mould and creating the uniform white rinds we all know right now.
“It’s regarded as a white mutant chosen from the gray-green species Penicillium commune for its colour in the beginning of the twentieth century,” the Paris-Saclay examine mentioned.
Sadly, in contrast to its cave-dwelling fungal counterparts, researchers discovered that Penicillium camemberti has a really low genetic range and declined capability to breed sexually.
“Our findings increase questions on the usage of restricted variety of clonal strains for cheese making, which tends to result in degeneration, limiting the chances for additional enchancment,” the examine mentioned.
That, in keeping with the CNRS report, means “it’s now very troublesome for producers to acquire enough portions of P. camemberti spores to inoculate their Normandy cheese manufacturing.”
Fall and rise
It’s not the primary time Camembert has confronted a disaster following the introduction of P. camemberti. In response to the late Patrick Lance, a British cheese skilled who authored a definitive information to France’s cheese, the industrialization and battle of the final century nearly noticed it worn out.
“Two world wars and an excessive amount of large enterprise almost introduced Camembert to its grave, besides in identify,” he wrote in his definitive 1989 tome “The French Cheese Ebook.”
“And this identify has been introduced into contempt by failure to guard it in opposition to the plenty of pasteurised manufacturing facility distortions of the components, perpetrated over nearly all of France and overseas.
To the rescue, in 1982, got here Appellation d’origine protégée (AOP) standing, which meant solely cheeses made in Normandy may carry the Camembert identify. That didn’t, nevertheless, cease additional tussles over whether or not true Camembert ought to be made with uncooked or pasteurized milk.
Those that have skilled the previous rises and falls of Camembert appear to be taking the cheese’s newest downside of their stride.
“My household has been making Camembert since 1891, 5 generations… I’ve by no means heard of this example earlier than,” Bruno Lefèvre, director basic of Les fromageries de Normandie, a regional cheesemakers’ affiliation, informed CNN.
“It’s true that cheesemakers have fought battles in opposition to the cheese that didn’t have a white look,” Lefèvre mentioned, including that the primary batches of Camembert his father made, greater than 50 years in the past, had been “blue, white and pink.”
However from his understanding, the colour distinction is a results of bacterial pigmentation.
“It’s linked to the sort of bacterium referred to as Brevibacterium linens, which has the power to kind an orange pigment. It’s certainly not a results of fungus exercise,” Lefèvre mentioned.
France is presently internet hosting its annual cheese truthful in Paris, gathering main cheesemakers from throughout the nation. Naturally, fading fungus has been a much-discussed matter. Lefèvre mentioned that individuals he has spoken with had been confused about the place the worry for Camembert’s future was coming from.
“I’ve made every kind of Camembert, from extra conventional ones to the extra industrial ones, I’ve by no means encountered points with my fungus,” Lefèvre mentioned.
“This examine has been broadly reported by the media. Perhaps the researchers had been attempting to make us cheesemakers panic, however thus far they haven’t succeeded,” he added.
Whereas the scientists have stood by their claims, they stress that there’s no hazard that Camembert is vanishing anytime quickly. “We all the time make it clear to journalists that there isn’t any short-term hazard to Camembert manufacturing,” researcher Tatiana Giraud informed CNN. “What our articles say is that there’s a nice homogenization of starters and that this reduces their capability to adapt, nothing extra.”
American cheese connection
In fact, preserving Camembert alive additionally implies that the cheese’s story can be saved alive. Supposedly, it was first created by a Normandy lady referred to as Marie Harel who picked up ideas from a fugitive priest from Brie, one other bastion of French cheesemaking. After discovering favor with Napoleon, it went on to play an surprising function in World Struggle I, which was commemorated with a statue.
The monument to Harel within the Normandy city of Vimoutiers, was truly first constructed by an American, in keeping with Camembert skilled Anne-Marie Cantin.
“An American physician first got here to Normandy after the First World Struggle asking to seek out the tomb of Marie Harel and later construct a statue for her,” she mentioned.
“To the shock of locals, who had struggled to seek out somebody who can converse English, he defined that he had used Camembert through the conflict to treatment sufferers and needed to return and thank the inventor.”
That statue was later destroyed in 1944 by American bombing through the Normandy landings and it was a gaggle of cheese manufacturing facility staff from Ohio who made a donation to construct a brand new one after the conflict, in keeping with Cantin.
The statue continues to be standing proudly right now within the city sq. of Vimoutiers in Normandy, with a plaque marking that it’s a reward supplied by “400 women and men making cheese in Van Wert, Ohio, USA.”
One other statue of Marie Harel stands again in Van Wert County Museum in Ohio, quietly marking a unprecedented and tacky relationship between France and the USA.
For extra CNN information and newsletters create an account at CNN.com
