Limit on gifts from friends would be ‘helpful’: ethics commissioner

Article content material

OTTAWA – The federal ethics commissioner says it might be “useful” if Parliament set a restrict on the worth of items members of cupboard might obtain from mates in gentle of the prime minister’s second journey to a good friend’s unique Jamaican property.

“It will be useful if there was a restrict. What’s the restrict and who units it? Clearly Parliament must set it. However I believe it might be useful to cope with the looks (of battle of curiosity) subject,” Ethics Commissioner Konrad von Finckenstein instructed the Nationwide Publish after talking to the Home ethics committee Thursday.

Article content material

Article content material

The commissioner has acknowledged that Prime Minister Justin Trudeau didn’t violate the Battle of Curiosity Act when he and his household spent 10 days at a $9,300-per-night personal property in Jamaica owned by longtime household mates without charge.

That’s as a result of the act doesn’t set a restrict on the quantity or worth of a present from a good friend as long as it doesn’t improperly advance the good friend’s personal pursuits.

However Thursday, von Finckenstein questioned if that exception ought to proceed to be limitless contemplating ongoing controversy over Trudeau’s free keep on the ultra-luxurious property.

“Because you’re speaking in regards to the Jamaica journey as an example, ought to there be a ceiling on items? Proper now, there’s a full exception for items from a good friend,” he instructed the committee. “If a present is just too giant, it could create the fallacious look and possibly we must always have a financial restrict on it.”

The commissioner declined to recommend a restrict when requested by Nationwide Publish after the committee, however joked {that a} “Ferrari” would exceed it in his opinion.

Opposition events have criticized Trudeau for vacationing together with his estranged spouse, Sophie Grégoire Trudeau, and their three kids on the resort free of charge whereas Canadians grapple with rising affordability points and rising meals, housing and utility prices.

Article content material

Article content material

Thursday, CBC Information reported that the journey additionally price taxpayers $230,000 in government-provided companies reminiscent of safety by the RCMP, lodging and meals for the RCAF flight crew in addition to two round-trip flights for presidency planes to Jamaica (as a result of one airplane broke down in Jamaica, requiring a second to be despatched).

Citing the report on the journey’s price to taxpayers Thursday, NDP MP Matthew Inexperienced requested von Finckenstein if he thought the Battle of Curiosity Act should be modified.

The commissioner mentioned one in every of his issues with the regulation is that it solely considers outright conflicts of curiosity versus the notion of battle of curiosity, which will be simply as damaging to the general public’s belief in authorities officers.

“Sadly, the act offers with conflicts of curiosity. There isn’t a obvious battle of curiosity provision,” he mentioned.

A 2017 Trudeau household trip to the Aga Khan’s island landed the prime minister in bother with the ethics commissioner’s workplace. Although Trudeau argued that the Aga Khan was a longtime household good friend so the journey was a suitable present, then-commissioner Mary Dawson disagreed that their relationship match the authorized definition of a friendship and concluded the prime minister had damaged the regulation.

Article content material

Testifying alongside von Finckenstein on Thursday, former ethics commissioner Mario Dion recommended it could even be time to assessment penalties for individuals who break ethics legal guidelines. The present regime is predicated on a “identify and disgrace” with very low financial sanctions potential.

“There’s an absence of direct penalty in relation to the act. It ought to be checked out. By way of the credibility of the system, it might assist if there was a potential sanction to be beneficial by the commissioner however to be imposed probably by the Home or by one other higher authority,” Dion mentioned.

Dion was the ethics commissioner who discovered Trudeau broke the ethics guidelines when he pressured then-Legal professional Common Jody Wilson-Raybould to think about giving building large SNC-Lavalin a deferred prosecution settlement as a substitute of going through felony prices for corruption in Libya.  

In his report, he highlighted frustrations with the truth that the federal government by no means allowed him to see paperwork that have been lined by cupboard confidence.

Article content material

Thursday, Dion revealed that he thought-about bringing the clerk of the privy council — the federal government’s prime bureaucrat — to court docket over its refusal to reveal these paperwork, however in the end determined it might be too lengthy and dear a course of.

“I used to be shocked (by the refusal) as a result of the Battle of Curiosity Act seems to point that the commissioner ought to have the arrogance in relation to paperwork lined by cupboard confidence,” Dion mentioned.

“I thought-about going to the Federal Courtroom to contest the clerk’s resolution. However over my 43-year profession within the public service, I all the time paid explicit consideration to how I used taxpayers’ funds, so I thought-about that it wasn’t price spending three years and two million {dollars} to determine if I ought to entry these paperwork.”

Our web site is the place for the most recent breaking information, unique scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark nationalpost.com and join our politics publication, First Studying, right here.

Article content material