In a video assertion outlining his place on abortion, former President Donald Trump falsely claimed that “all authorized students, either side, needed and in reality demanded” that Roe v. Wade “be ended.” Authorized students informed us that was “utter nonsense” and “patently absurd.”
Roe, the 1973 Supreme Courtroom ruling that established a constitutional proper to abortion, was overturned by the Supreme Courtroom on June 24, 2022, by a 5-4 ruling within the case Dobbs v. Jackson Girls’s Well being Group, which involved a Mississippi regulation. Authorized students wrote many amicus briefs in that case supporting Roe and opposing the state regulation.
As an illustration, 12 students in reproductive rights wrote: “Overturning many years of precedent—precedent on which ladies have relied and round which ladies have deliberate their lives—would have catastrophic results on all ladies, however most acutely on ladies of shade.” The American Bar Affiliation, whose members embody legal professionals and regulation professors, wrote in its transient that “the ABA has constantly opposed overturning Roe v. Wade,” in addition to a subsequent Supreme Courtroom ruling that reaffirmed Roe and “legal guidelines that search to bar abortion earlier than viability.”
Trump appointed three of the 9 justices on the Supreme Courtroom, giving the court docket the conservative majority it wanted to overturn Roe. “I used to be proudly the particular person answerable for the ending of one thing that each one authorized students, either side, needed and in reality demanded be ended. Roe v. Wade, they needed it ended,” Trump mentioned in a video posted on Fact Social on April 8.
“This one is clearly false. Most authorized students, like most Individuals, didn’t need Roe overturned,” Mary Ziegler, a professor of regulation on the College of California, Davis, informed us in an electronic mail. Ziegler, the creator of six books on the abortion debate and the regulation, mentioned that “we will identify any variety of professors who submitted briefs to SCOTUS asking Roe not to be overturned.”
David S. Cohen, a professor of regulation at Drexel College and an knowledgeable in authorized points regarding abortion, informed us Trump’s declare was “utter nonsense.”
Marie Griffith, a professor at Washington College in St. Louis and the director of the John C. Danforth Heart on Faith and Politics, mentioned in an electronic mail: “As you could have likely guessed, it’s patently absurd to say that each one authorized students ‘needed and in reality demanded’ that Roe v Wade be ended. Undoubtedly false.”
These specialists mentioned some students have had criticisms of the authorized reasoning in Roe, however that doesn’t imply they needed the ruling overturned. The late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg mentioned it will have been higher to base the abortion rights ruling on the equal safety clause of the Structure, or gender equality, versus a proper to privateness below the due course of clause, which is how the opinion was written.
“Some authorized students on the left needed abortion rights to be grounded in a unique constitutional dwelling—i.e., equal safety moderately than due course of,” Greer Donley, an affiliate professor on the College of Pittsburgh Legislation College and an knowledgeable on abortion and the regulation, informed us. “This view was a disagreement on reasoning in Roe, however not on the end result. Progressive authorized students had been pretty unified of their view {that a} nationwide constitutional proper to abortion was essential, and that overturning Roe could be problematic, if not catastrophic. So it’s blatantly incorrect to argue that each one authorized students needed Roe to be overturned.”
In his video, Trump reiterated the false concept that abortion is now “the place all people needed it from a authorized standpoint.” Public opinion polls have proven a majority of Individuals opposed overturning Roe.
In a 2019 survey performed by the Pew Analysis Heart, 70% mentioned they didn’t need the Supreme Courtroom to fully overturn Roe, and earlier surveys by the middle additionally discovered a majority in opposition to abolishing Roe.
Because the Dobbs case, a number of polls have discovered a majority of Individuals oppose the Supreme Courtroom’s ruling overturning Roe. A February Marquette Legislation College ballot and a July 2023 CNN ballot discovered that 67% and 64%, respectively, disapproved of the Dobbs determination. In a Might 2023 ballot by Gallup, 61% mentioned overturning Roe was a “dangerous factor.”
Trump’s Place
Trump’s video mentioned his place on abortion is that states ought to make their very own selections. “The states will decide by vote or laws or maybe each. And no matter they determine should be the regulation of the land. On this case, the regulation of the state,” he mentioned. “Many could have a unique variety of weeks or some could have extra conservative than others and that’s what they are going to be.”
He mentioned he was “strongly in favor of exceptions for rape, incest and the lifetime of the mom.”
His April 8 assertion comes every week after the Florida Supreme Courtroom allowed a six-week abortion ban, with exceptions for rape, incest and the lifetime of the mom, to face. It is going to take impact on Might 1. The court docket additionally permitted a measure to seem on ballots this November asking voters whether or not they help an modification to the state structure to ban restrictions on abortion earlier than a fetus is viable exterior the womb.
President Joe Biden’s reelection marketing campaign has been operating TV adverts that declare Trump helps a “nationwide ban” on abortion. In February, the New York Instances reported, primarily based on nameless sources, that Trump had privately mentioned he was in favor of a nationwide ban after 16 weeks, with exceptions for rape, incest and the lifetime of the mom. However till his current assertion, Trump had averted making his place clear publicly. He didn’t seek advice from requires a nationwide ban within the video.
In an announcement, Biden mentioned, “If Donald Trump is elected and the MAGA Republicans in Congress put a nationwide abortion ban on the Resolute Desk, Trump will signal it into regulation.”
Repeated Falsehood on Abortion ‘After Start’
Trump additionally repeated a false declare he has ceaselessly made, saying Democrats “help abortion as much as and even past the ninth month.” He claimed, “The child is born, the newborn is executed after beginning.” That might be murder, and it’s unlawful.
As we’ve written, many Democrats help the Roe ruling, which mentioned states may outlaw abortion after fetal viability, however with exceptions for dangers to the life or well being of the mom. Many Republicans have objected to the well being exception, saying it will permit abortion for any purpose.
Again in 2019, Trump made related claims in reference to a GOP invoice calling for jail time for well being care practitioners who don’t present sure medical care “[i]n the case of an abortion or tried abortion that outcomes in a baby born alive.” Particularly, the invoice would have required well being suppliers “to protect the life and well being of the kid as a fairly diligent and conscientious well being care practitioner would render to another baby born alive on the similar gestational age.” As we wrote then, Democrats mentioned the laws was pointless and geared toward proscribing entry to authorized abortion, whereas Republicans mentioned it was about defending infants.
A federal regulation isn’t essential to prosecute the intentional killing of a child as a murder. “States can and do punish folks for killing kids who’re born alive,” Ziegler informed us on the time. “Most felony legal guidelines are on the state stage not the federal stage.”
The overwhelming majority of abortions within the U.S. happen early in being pregnant. In line with information from the Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention, 93.5% of abortions in 2021 had been carried out at or earlier than 13 weeks of gestation, and fewer than 1% had been carried out at or after 21 weeks.
Editor’s notice: FactCheck.org doesn’t settle for promoting. We depend on grants and particular person donations from folks such as you. Please contemplate a donation. Bank card donations could also be made via our “Donate” web page. When you favor to provide by test, ship to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Coverage Heart, 202 S. thirty sixth St., Philadelphia, PA 19104.
